On the Difference Between Who We Are and Who Others Believe Us to Be
We want people to know us, recognise our character, anticipate our preferences and understand our intentions. There’s comfort in being understood without having to explain ourselves.
I came face to face with the darker side of this desire after a breakdown. During the depths of a longstanding depression that culminated in the loss of my job, identity and direction, I felt increasingly unseen, misunderstood and misrepresented.
The comfort of being known had become something altogether different. People seemed to recognise a version of me that I no longer recognised in myself.
It was an incredibly painful way of discovering that how others remember us can be at odds with how we experience ourselves.
Of course, we assume we know ourselves, but that’s a whole other essay. We don’t. If we did, we wouldn’t be so riddled with the coping mechanisms of childhood, or so frequently surprised by our own behaviour. Much of living is an empirical process of discovering who we are.
But to then exist as that unfinished human puzzle in someone else’s mind introduces another layer of uncertainty.
Our identities are assembled from selected encounters, half-remembered conversations and emotional interpretations. The result is something like an abstract portrait, an impression of another person’s essence, painted as much with the observer’s biases and experiences as with the subject’s actual character.
Our parents remember our childhood selves, old friends remember us as young adults, and colleagues remember the person we became at work. We exist in a gallery of interpretations, none of which is entirely coherent or representative.
And these portraits are not neutral.
Once someone forms an impression, subsequent encounters tend to reinforce it. Decide that someone is selfish or generous, and ambiguous behaviour can be interpreted to support either conclusion.
A sarcastic remark becomes a confession. A moment of frustration becomes a character trait. An argument made for intellectual exploration becomes a sincerely held conviction.
Memory doesn’t merely preserve an event. It assigns meaning to it.
We favour consistency because it helps us navigate the complexity of life. Knowing what to expect from others makes relationships manageable. But when someone behaves contrary to our expectations, the discrepancy can feel unsettling.
The formerly timid person’s newfound confidence seems arrogant. The ambitious person’s contentment looks like resignation. Someone who once needed our support becomes independent, and we interpret their autonomy as rejection.
Their development threatens the portrait we’ve constructed.
What's more concerning is that we can begin to accommodate these expectations ourselves. We recognise the version of us that others expect to encounter and unconsciously step back into character.
The quiet one remains quiet. The dependable one never admits to struggling. The difficult one becomes defensive in anticipation of being misunderstood.
In this way, another person’s interpretation can influence our behaviour, which then becomes further evidence supporting their original interpretation.
We become prints of ourselves rather than new, unfinished works.
Forgetting is a mercy in this respect.
It allows the messy and misunderstood past to gradually lose its authority over the present. Old impressions soften, embarrassing moments fade, and people are afforded the opportunity to change without continually defending themselves against everything they’ve ever said or done.
Of course, forgetting isn’t always virtuous. Memory is essential to trust, accountability and learning. We would be foolish to disregard someone’s history simply because they wished to escape it.
The problem isn’t remembering. It’s the conviction that our interpretation of what we remember must be correct.
And then modernity complicated matters by turning our portraits into pixels.
Suddenly, our conversations were recorded, our words archived, our behaviour documented and our histories made searchable.
We gained the ability to preserve extraordinary amounts of information, without preserving understanding.
Consider the extraordinary popularity of true crime documentaries, with their endless supply of humanity’s darker episodes. Or celebrity biographies in which entire identities are assembled from interviews, correspondence and recollections.
These are fascinating demonstrations of how differently people can interpret the same individual in an attempt to illustrate the whole.
A former friend recalls warmth and generosity. A colleague remembers arrogance. A family member describes someone neither would recognise.
Then come the text messages, presented as evidence of intention.
Read almost any private conversation without the context shared by its participants and consider how differently a stranger might interpret it.
A playful insult becomes abuse. A hurried question becomes aggression. An exaggerated remark becomes a declaration of belief.
The words may be preserved perfectly, yet their meaning can be profoundly distorted.
This is perhaps the peculiar danger of permanent records. They can give the appearance of objectivity simply because the underlying evidence seems authentic.
We mistake the accuracy of the record for the accuracy of our understanding.
And now we’re inviting machines to remember us.
Artificial intelligence is increasingly capable of retaining conversations, identifying patterns, inferring preferences and constructing working models of the people it interacts with.
At first glance, this seems like an extraordinary convenience. A system that remembers our interests, anticipates our needs and understands our intentions promises precisely the kind of recognition we look for in one another.
But what happens when its understanding also lacks nuance?
A moment of despair might become a defining characteristic. Sarcasm, exaggeration and devil’s advocacy might be interpreted literally.
The machine can preserve the words without the wry smile, the raised eyebrow, the shared history or the fleeting circumstances that gave them meaning.
And unlike a human recollection that gradually fades, these interpretations may remain available indefinitely.
The more troubling possibility is not simply that a machine misunderstands us, but that its misunderstanding begins to shape our future interactions.
An incorrect assumption influences a response. That response subtly directs the conversation. Our reaction provides further information, which may then reinforce the original assumption.
A portrait begins to paint itself.
We already experience something similar with recommendation algorithms. Engage with a particular subject and the system offers more of it, gradually narrowing the world it presents. Curiosity is interpreted as preference, preference becomes identity, and identity determines what comes next.
What began as an attempt to understand us becomes a mechanism for defining us.
And because these systems are designed to be useful, agreeable and personalised, we may not immediately recognise the boundaries of the portrait we’re being encouraged to inhabit.
We might even begin adjusting our behaviour to accommodate the machine’s expectations, just as we do with other people.
We already edit ourselves for employers, family, friends and strangers. Must we now consider how an offhand remark might be remembered by an artificial observer?
The freedom to explore an idea without adopting it, to express frustration without being defined by it, or simply to contradict ourselves, is an essential part of being human.
A perfectly consistent person would have very little room to grow.
There is an inescapable tension here.
We need continuity to maintain relationships. Without some stable understanding of one another, every encounter would require us to begin again. Trust, affection and familiarity depend upon memory.
But development requires a degree of freedom from that continuity.
We need to be recognised as the people we’ve been without being permanently confined to them.
Perhaps the answer lies not in forgetting, but in remembering provisionally.
To recognise that our impressions are interpretations rather than facts. That the person standing before us may have changed since we last paid attention. That even a perfectly accurate recollection can support an entirely mistaken conclusion.
This requires a willingness to revise our understanding rather than continually defend it.
And maybe the greatest kindness we can offer another person is not the assurance that we know them, but the curiosity to discover who they might have become.
To be understood is comforting. To be defined is constraining.
Somewhere between those two lies the freedom to remain unfinished.
My breakdown still echoes. The responsibility should belong to those doing the remembering, but it falls to me to introduce my altered self, and it isn't easy. When I bump into someone, they often ask what I'm up to and then answer for me: "Still bumming around?" They're walking the gallery, thinking they've seen this painting before. Can I show them the newer rooms?